COMMENTARY: I came across a truck parked on the side of a dirt road while I was hunting last week with a red “Make America Great Again” cap displayed on the dashboard. The plate on the front read, “You can’t fix stupid.”
I’ve been thinking about it ever since. The sort of othering promoted by President Donald Trump and his MAGA agenda is sweeping the globe as populist movements grow in response to economic pressures. That, coupled with our long history of colonization and racism, is feeding anti-immigrant movements. Divides between the ideological left and right are widening. Those who would hold the middle are being marginalized.
With younger generations consistently moving America in a more progressive direction, the Republican Party is increasingly abandoning democracy in an attempt to hold power. Some still believe in working to bring people of color, women and young people into the GOP, but the party as a whole has embraced nationalism and anti-democratic policies like reducing polling places and canceling presidential primaries.
I understand the urge. Too many people whose families built wealth over generations lost it in the 2008 recession, then lost health care when Barack Obama was president. Trump provides a boogeyman — immigrants — and promises to protect a life people fear is slipping away.
But America, in all its imperfect glory, is at its best when we act with the hope of a shared purpose instead fear of others. The white nationalist MAGA agenda, not immigrants, is the greatest threat to our way of life.
Research by Harvard political scientist Daniel Ziblatt suggests that democracies need strong center-right parties to survive the creep of fascism. So Trump’s success in bullying out of Congress those conservatives who would stand up to his agenda is especially troubling. To stop this threat, we need democracy-loving Republicans.
The Republican Party of New Mexico should be a bastion of moderate conservatism. Republicans can’t win most offices in this state any other way. Republicans here should know better than to embrace the kidnapping and traumatizing of migrant children and wasting public money on an ineffective border wall.
Instead, former U.S. Rep. Steve Pearce, who now heads the state GOP, has wholeheartedly embraced the Trump agenda. Where are the independent Republicans? Some have landed in our neighbor city of El Paso.
Jon Barela, a former N.M. economic development secretary who once ran for Congress in Albuquerque, is working to build the border economy across three states in two nations as CEO of the Borderplex, and he often speaks out against the president’s rhetoric. Heather Wilson, a former congresswoman from Albuquerque who was Trump’s first Air Force secretary, is the president of the University of Texas-El Paso. While in Washington she fought against Trump’s efforts to create a Space Force as a separate branch of the military.
The Democratic, pro-immigration stronghold in far southwest Texas seems to be a spot not only for refugees from Latin America, but also for some important conservatives.
I’m sad that Rep. Will Hurd, a black, moderate Republican who represents the House district east of El Paso, isn’t seeking re-election. He is instead focusing on building a more ethnically diverse GOP. While the cynic in me thinks it’s too late for that, his stubborn hope, to be honest, helped sparked this column. We need more of it.
There are others. I give Utah’s Mitt Romney credit for running into the burning building by seeking election to the U.S. Senate while so many others were fleeing to save themselves. I wish Arizona’s Jeff Flake and others had stayed to fight alongside him.
That’s difficult when your party turns to white nationalism and the other party beats you up endlessly. The left has aided Trump in bullying Republicans who value democracy over party out of Congress.
I was excited last year when the Koch-funded LIBRE Initiative hosted a panel discussion on immigration reform in Las Cruces. My girlfriend Sarah Silva joined Barela and other conservatives on that panel who understand that immigration is instrumental to America’s greatness, and who still value common ground and compromise.
Sarah faced some backlash from the left for having a conversation with Barela and others at a Koch-funded event. Othering isn’t unique to the right, though it’s much worse in that corner of the ideological spectrum at this moment in history.
But the ideological purity the left trends toward isn’t helping hold the line against fascism any more than the blind party loyalty that has consumed the right.
The removal of the most fascist-leaning president in modern history is a critical step to preserving what makes America great. We need people like Barela, Wilson, Hurd and Flake to stay active. We need Romney to be more vocal. We need more influential white Republicans to join Barela and Hurd in the fray, like state Sen. John McCollister in Nebraska has done, and not leave it to the few prominent GOP people of color to lead efforts to stop the party’s descent into white nationalism. Is there a GOP state senator in New Mexico with McCollister’s courage?
We also need the left to work with the Republicans who stand up for what’s right. Such alliances are quintessentially American. They’re necessary if we’re to successfully defend everything about America that is wonderful.
Sarah’s grandfather, Ramón Jiménez, came to the United States from Mexico decades ago under the bracero program. He was eventually able to bring his family with him. He still speaks primarily Spanish. The land where he farms pecans has three homes on it. Two of his children live there with him and their families. His farm is a testament to the greatness immigrants bring to the United States. Life there is a mix of English and Spanish and always a celebration of family and freedom.
I photographed Sarah’s grandfather standing on that patch of land three years ago with pecan trees and an American flag behind him. In the photo, this entrepreneur looks proud and content.
That’s America, when we choose to be our best. America at its best is also Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman testifying Tuesday in the House about Trump’s inappropriate demands of Ukraine.
Lt. Col. Vindman shared that in the Soviet Union, which his father left four decades ago to bring his family to the United States, his acts of raising concerns about the president and testifying publicly “would surely cost me my life.”
America is different, he said, addressing his dad: “Do not worry. I will be fine for telling the truth.”
Lt. Col. Vindman’s faith in America makes America great. The GOP attacks on his immigrant heritage do the opposite.
The United States has often met waves of immigration with fear that’s always been proven wrong. We must refuse to give in to that fear now. We must interrupt our own senseless othering and find ways to bridge our differences. Our task is to dig deep to find hope, understanding and courage, and then to act, together.
We can start by standing up for what’s right, like Lt. Col. Vindman. And we can start, as Las Cruces, Deming and El Paso have done with diverse ideological support, by creating welcoming spaces for the migrants Trump mistreats. That’s a model the rest of the nation should emulate.
We can build from there, regardless of whether Trump is removed from office by the Senate or defeated in the next election.